Catnaps are for kittens, not for babies!
July 15, 2009 — Alenka | Posted in Book Reviews, Positive Discipline. 7 Comments »
My baby is catnapping. It’s driving me nuts: I spend 40 minutes getting him to fall asleep, and then he wakes up 20 minutes later! He wakes up with a broad smile, his arms and legs wiggle vigorously, so I reluctantly take him out of the bed… just to have a very cranky baby hanging on my shoulder until the rest of the nap. How come?
First of all, I refuse to try “cry it out approach”. It is harmful for baby’s development, his confidence, his future. You can see more here: “Crying it out” may damage baby’s brain.
So, what’s left?
In my favorite “sleep” book by Elizabeth Pantley, The No-Cry Sleep Solution: Gentle Ways to Help Your Baby Sleep Through the Night , there is a section on the importance of naps. Gentle, kind, loving approach of that book was a lifesaver for our first kid, who woke up every 15 minutes during the night! Now I needed something for my second one, something to get him to sleep longer during each nap, to fall asleep all by himself, to wake up happy.
Imagine how thrilled I was to find out that there is a new book by Elizabeth Pantley, The No-Cry Nap Solution: Guaranteed Gentle Ways to Solve All Your Naptime Problems.
At first I was doubtful: do I need another book just for naps? Apparently, I did: my baby was turning 4 monts and there was no light seen at the end of the tunnel. Both of us needed him to be able to sleep.
The book has three parts:
Nap Magic
Here are the physiological and psychological factors influencing sleep; sleep stages; charts with duration and benefits of each sleep stage; how naps effect baby’s development and daily activities; and tables how much nap is required at each age (up to adulthood). This chapter helps to identify the sleep dynamics, identify sleep patterns of your particular kid and work out a realistic goal for both of you.
Newborn Babies
This chapter is specific to the most little ones. It has lots of information on how to introduce good habits early, how to prevent problems in the future… and how to start solving issues right away. We realized that my son’s catnapping is abnormal quite early, so these steps were the first ones for us to utilize. However, I wish I started reading it even earlier – may be we could prevent this problem in the first place?
This chapter is useful even to the parents whose babies are already past adorable (and sleepless) newborn stage, since it has many concepts and suggestions that could be utilized with older babies as well.
Solving Napping Problems: Customized Solutions for Your Family
This is the biggest part of the book. It has lots of suggestions. Some of those suggestions weren’t new to us – we’ve read them in other books by Elizabeth Pantley. Others – were as new, as helpful! We were thrilled and eager to try the new ideas! It has a section for most of the sleep issues: catnaps, resisting naps, shifting schedules (oh, it used to drive me nuts with my first one! I wish I had that book then!!!), teaching baby to fall asleep in her bed instead of a car, sling, swing or, the most beloved place for all babies – in her parent’s arms. It has suggestions for babies that wake up too often to nurse; babies who need swinging, bouncing, gliding to fall asleep; newborns who prefer sleeping on his stomach; and even colic care.
Honestly, I haven’t encountered an issue that isn’t covered here. This book quickly became my bible, just like its “sibling” – No cry to Sleep Solution.
…
So, the results? We are slowly working on it. My little one just turned five months. We can’t try every solution in a book due to the conflict of schedules with my older one, but even those solutions that we’ve tried helped us to improve the situation dramatically. As I am writing this article, my little one is finally sleeping in the time-slot that works for everyone in the family, in the location where I want him to be during the afternoon naps, and… it’s been already one and a half hours since he finally drifted to the dreamland!
As for my older one: today is especially memorable, since we had a great nap-success with him as well. With the help of the No-Cry to Sleep Solution book, we managed to teach him how to fall asleep in his own bed, without our help and without tears. That was more then two years ago. Naps is a whole other story: I was always so worried he would stop napping altogether, so I was afraid to change anything about our technique, since it is so important for him to sleep! However, slowly, I started working some of Pantley’s suggestions into our routine and… today he fell asleep all by himself! I was putting baby to bed in another room, anxiously listening for his chat with himself and terribly worrying that this conversation would excite him so much, that he would miss a nap – a disaster in our house. Nevertheless he did it! (Now I almost sound like Dora the Explorer). Yes, he did manage to fall asleep all by himself! Both of us felt very proud. And the little one just felt good – I had time to put him to bed and he got a nice hour and a half nap as well.
I’ve got to admit, I owe this book a lot!!


October 14, 2010 at 11:59 am
Crying it out will NOT damage a baby’s brain. 10 minutes of crying can result in hours of good restful sleep for baby and parents. Show me one proven result where crying was 100 percent without a doubt the cause of brain damage in a child. Sounds like that empty statement is a way to promote that book.
October 16, 2010 at 7:09 pm
Very interesting opinion. To each his own, I guess. As for book promotion: I have nothing to gain from it. I just tend to feel passionate about things that I believe in.
October 17, 2010 at 5:29 am
Hello..
Maybe crying will not damage a baby’s brain, but I guess it can make him feel unheard/ignores by his care takers.
April 7, 2011 at 4:03 pm
Crying out does NOT damage a baby’s brain. That’s the most ridiculous statement I’ve ever heard. Actually not sleeping damages a baby’s brain is more accurate. I guess people will say anything to promote their “ideas”.
April 9, 2011 at 6:55 pm
You are totally right: people will say anything to promote their ideas. That’s why scientists perform studies, test their hypothesis and prove their theories. I have more about here: Crying Out Damages Baby’s Brain or you can just read an original article in Washington Post: http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=a1a74c84-c59d-414d-bbb7-3860fee988f1
Check it out. I always welcome any discussion.
January 4, 2012 at 6:32 pm
Hi Alenka,
My baby is 4 months and 1 week old. He is a cat-napper. Sleeping 3,4 or sometimes even 5 short 30-40 minutes naps. We are going insane! Do you have any suggestions? We put him to bed around 6:30-7pm and he usually sleeps about 10 hrs. I need help! thx
January 10, 2012 at 9:49 pm
Melissa, I loved the book by Elizabeth Pantley “No cry to Nap Solution”. It really helped us! There are so many things that we tried… Just recently I was transferring him from a stroller to the normal bed for his naps and rereading this book again. There chapters and chapters dedicated on how timings, routines, adjusting the lighting, sounds, bedding, sleepware can help. When my little one was three-four months old, catnaps were also our among our biggest issues. In a book there is a table what are the common sleep patterns for different ages, different stages, different styles both for the night and day.
After-all, the biggest tip for catnapping was timing when it generally happens (when transition to his next sleeping phase must occur), getting to him 5 minutes earlier to be ready to help him to go back to sleep. Our babies were napping in strollers, so rocking worked well for us. With time, patience and practice, we eventually had our babies sleep for 2-3 hours long. When they were older and we transferred them to the normal bed, turning on the lullabies and rubbing their backs helped them to adjust. I still occasionally walk into my little one’s room, glance at the time, and just keep the room dark and sleepy by turning the lullabies again, gently patting him for two seconds and then both of us are enjoying another hour and a half of his sleep.
It can be frustrating, but the result is well worth the effort! And my recent venture in the book “Sleepless America” only made us even more diligent on keeping up with nap schedules for both of our kids as long as we can…