Can TV/computer be harmful or helpful for kids development?

As far as I remember, American Academy of Pediatrics recommends the parents to avoid showing TV to their kids until two years old. As for educational videos, there are a lot more videos that just claim to be educational, like Baby Einsteins: Baby Einstein videos harmful for kids?

There is even an article in Time magazine that links early TV watching to autism: Does Watching TV Cause Autism?

I don't know how much this particular research can be trusted, since my friend with a PHD in psychology just has been attending a seminar on autism, which stated that the scientific community believes that autism is a purely genetic disease, and all other "findings" are just scandalous ways to get public attention.

Yet, I think it is better to be safe, then sorry. There is a great deal of material linking ADHD, poor school performance, delayed development, etc. with TV watching:

As for the computer - it is just another TV screen. Besides, it is a TV screen that is quite close. And as you can see from the articles, it is not even the radiation that is the major problem, but the 2D format of presentation (TV is not really 3D as it seems) to the children and how it can affect the development of brain cells.

So... I think everything has to be taken with a grain of salt. You always weigh the risks and the benefits. For ourselves, we limited TV (or rather DVD, since our TV is not hooked up to any channels) usage only for long car trips, since my son hated the car rides. I thought it was better for him to enjoy some educational DVD then scream the whole way through. There are plenty of very good educational DVDs, you can find the most recommended ones here: http://www.childandme.com/teach-your-child-read-multimedia#dvd

As for the computer, since we didn't watch ANY TV during the day, AND my son didn't like the flash cards (and we moved onto phrases, so it was more and more difficult to retain his attention), around 18 months we introduced a computer. I'd sit him on my lap and for the next 5 minutes we'd watch 10 presentations one after another, some starfall.com... and it worked great for us! I figured that 15 mintues a day of screen time on a weekday and one DVD in a month on a weekend - can't do that much damage. Now I show less presentations (about 5-6), and let him play at starfall.com a little longer, by himself, though - just once a day, or once in a few days. At two and a half, is he really good with a regular mouse, navigating anywhere he pleases. There is a list of other good websites here, http://www.childandme.com/teach-your-child-read-multimedia#web
Honestly, at two and a half I didn't find anything other then starfall, that I thought was worth spending the time in front of the computer. I think the other sites are geared at a little older kids. I might be wrong - many people delightfully use them.

Now, at 2 1/2 I started showing him some DVDs quite regularly: I think he is much older now, so twice a week (usually on weekends, when he doesn't see the computer anyway) is OK. And my husband, who gets up early with him, and lets me sleep a bit late on weekends, is very grateful for a morning break as well.

Even now, when I was searching for a daycare for my son, one of my first questions was if kids are shown TV. If there was even a hint of positive answer, that daycare was off my list permanently. I'd rather chose myself how to use the screen time, what to watch and how to limit it.

This is just another personal view on the issue. You would have to decide for yourself, and most probably it would depend on how much you, personally, watch TV. As I said, ours isn't even hooked up to anything but a DVD player, so we occasionally enjoy a DVD with my husband on a weekend. It is easy to have TV limiting rules if they apply to ourselves, not just the kids. I have a friend whose TV is always turned on. Just for a background. So her daughter was very good with a TV control before she could crawl, and is watching a tremendous amount of cartoons, TV programs, etc. While I wouldn't be thrilled about such situation, my friend just laughs: "How can we limit it if we, ourselves, can't live without a TV"? So, your own TV habits are probably going to be the biggest deciding factor.

What do you think? Please share your opinion in the comments below.

Comments

Watching TV as well as all

Watching TV as well as all other activities with the children should be rationally controlled. It's Ok for kids to watch TV. I do beleive in inevitable and benefitial progress and technology. If you show your children educational and fun presentations on computer, why to skip educational and fun stuff on TV? Just don't overdo it, and it will bring more benefit than harm. The same thing with sports, play time, cleaning, etc. Even books. You don't want your children to spend the whole day reading. They would miss life.
TV, you like it or not, is a big party of modern life. So, just accept it, but watch the time and quality of your child's viewing.


I agree that TV should be

I agree that TV should be rationally controlled but I think one of the problems with TV that it is easy to let it go, and it will get abused. TV removes social interaction between parent and the child. How many parents sit down with the child and help him or her to understand what is happening on the TV. There is definitely an educational benefit to TV but it has to be weighted against the social benefits. Almost, any other activity is part social and thus in my eyes has more benefit.


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <br> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.
CAPTCHA
Please enter four letters showing on the picture:
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.